24 Top Cosmetic and Personal Care Ingredients
Myths
MYTH #1: ALBUMIN
The chief ingredient in artificial face lifts. It is being touted as
a wrinkle treatment. The last time a serious case concerning consumer claims
came up was in the 1960's. Both of these products were temporary wrinkle
removers. The formulas contained a bovine serum albumin, which, when dried,
formed a film over wrinkles, thus making wrinkles less obvious (Brumberg).
MYTH #2: BENTONITE
This is a naturally occurring mineral used in facial masks. It differs
from true clay, kaolin, in that when it is mixed with liquid it forms a
gel. It can have sharp edges that scratch the skin. Most bentonites can
be drying to the skin (Hampton). Bentonite is used in formulations and
masks. It forms films that are gas impermeable, effectively trapping toxins
and CO2 in the skin that need to vent and escape, suffocating the skin
by shutting out the vitally needed oxygen.
MYTH #3: BIOTIN (Vitamin H)
An exotic ingredient promoted as being necessary and beneficial for
skin and hair care. A deficiency of this vitamin has been associated with
greasy scalps and baldness in rats and other experimental animals. Fur-bearing
animals, however, have a very different hair growth from human beings.
Biotin deficiency in man is extremely rare. Biotin is considered a worthless
additive in cosmetic products (Chase). The molecular size of Biotin is
too large to penetrate the skin.
MYTH #4: COLLAGEN
Some companies imply that collagen can support the skin's own collagen
network. Others claim it can be absorbed to moisturize skin. The Collagen
in creams and
lotions acts like any protein ingredient in that it merely provides
a coating on the skin's surface (Chase). The Collagen molecule cannot penetrate
your skin because it is much too large to be absorbed by the epidermis
(Brumberg). ...Collagen, elastin, or other proteins, and amino acids cannot
get into the skin through topical application. The molecules of these substances
are simply too large to penetrate your skin (Novick). Cosmetics manufacturers
have heralded it as a new wonder ingredient, but according to medical experts,
it cannot affect the skin's own collagen when applied topically (Winter).
MYTH #5: ELASTIN
(Not cross-linked Elastin) Another ingredient promoted as being beneficial
for skin and hair care. Elastin is included in some skin care products,
but nowhere near as much as collagen. It too cannot be absorbed by the
epidermis (Brumberg). In a cosmetic product, they cannot restore tone to
skin. When used in such products as moisturizers, they act like all other
commercial proteins by forming a film that holds moisture (Chase).
MYTH #6: GLYCERIN
Promoted as being a beneficial humectant. This is a clear, syrupy liquid
made by chemically combining water and fat. The water splits the fat into
smaller components glycerol and fatty acids. It improves the spreading
qualities of creams and lotions and prevents them from losing water through
evaporation. Glycerin, however, has a tendency to draw water out of the
skin and so can make dry skin dryer (Chase). A solvent, humectant, and
emollient in many cosmetics, it absorbs moisture from the air and therefore
helps keep moisture in creams and other products, even if the consumer
leaves the cap off the container (Winter). SEE HUMECTANTS. Unless the humidity
of the air is over 65%, Glycerin will pull the moisture out of the skin,
drying you from the inside out.
MYTH #7: HUMECTANTS
Ingredients that draw moisture to and aid in moisturizing skin. Most
moisturizers contain humectants that act as water attractors, they actually
pull moisture out of your skin (Valmy). The problem with humectants, including
propylene glycol and glycerin is that although they are most effective
when you are in areas with high humidity, if you are going to be in an
extremely low humidity atmosphere, such as in an airplane or even a dry
room, they can actually take moisture from your skin. Here's why: Humectants
are on the search for moisture that can be absorbed from the environment.
If the environment is so drying that there is no moisture to be had, they
will get it from the next best source - your skin. When this happens, the
ingredient, which is supposed to help your skin retain moisture, instead
does the opposite (Brumberg). A substance used to preserve the moisture
content of materials, especially in hand creams and lotions (Winter). SEE
GLYCERIN, PROPYLENE GLYCOL. These are natural or synthetic compounds that
are used to prevent water loss and drying of the skin. They also form a
smooth feel to cosmetic lotions. Some are safe, some aren't.
MYTH #8: HYPOALLERGENIC
A product to which you are not allergic. Hypoallergenic means "less
than" and the word hypoallergenic tells the consumer that the manufacturer
believes the product has fewer allergens than other products. There are
no federal regulations defining allergens, nor are there any guidelines.
So "hypoallergenic" has little meaning (Brumberg).
MYTH #9: KAOLIN
A very fine natural clay originally from Mt. Kaolin in China, hence
the name. Quite drying and may be dehydrating to the skin. It also may
be contaminated with impurities (Hampton). It is used in formulations and
masks, forms films that are gas impermeable. It effectively traps toxins
and CO2 in the skin that need to vent and escape, then suffocates the skin
by shutting out the vitally needed oxygen.
MYTH #10: LANOLIN
A beneficial moisturizer. Advertisers have found that the words "contains
Lanolin" help to sell a product and have promoted it as being able to "penetrate
the skin better than other oils," although there is little scientific proof
of this. Lanolin has been found to be a common skin sensitizer causing
allergic contact skin rashes (Winter). Lanolin usually contains pesticides
used on sheep and wool.
MYTH #11: LAURAMIDE DEA
Lauramide DEA is a partly natural, partly synthetic chemical used to
build lather and thicken various cosmetic products, is also used in dishwashing
detergents for its grease-cutting ability. It can be drying to the hair,
cause skin and scalp itching, and allergic reactions (Hampton).
MYTH #12: LIPOSOMES
Nanosphenes or Micellization - Ultimate anti-aging agent. Liposomes
are one of the newest entries in the "fountain of youth" arena. According
to one recent theory, cellular aging involves the edification of skin cell
membranes. Liposomes, which are tiny bags of fat and thymus gland extract
suspended in a gel, are supposed to merge with your aging skin cells, revive
them, and add moisture to them. Current scientific understanding does not
support the rigidification theory. The cell membranes of young and old
persons are alike. As a result, it is likely that liposome-containing moisturizers
represent nothing more than another expensive allure (Novick).
MYTH #13: MINERAL OIL
A beneficial moisturizer. Mineral oil is an oil manufactured from crude
oil. It is a mixture of liquid hydrocarbons separated from petroleum. Dr.
T. G. Randolph, an allergist, has found that this and many other cosmetic
chemicals cause petrochemical hypersensitivity. The allergic reactions
can become quite serious in time, leading to arthritis, migraine, hyperkinesis,
epilepsy, and diabetes. Taken internally, Mineral Oil binds the fat soluble
Vitamins A, D and E and carries them unabsorbed out of the body. Although
little mineral oil is able to penetrate the skin, this tendency is so dangerous
that Adelle Davis in Let's Eat Right to Keep Fit says that she "personally
would be afraid to use this oil even in baby oils, cold creams, and other
cosmetics" (New York: Harcourt, Brace, Jovanovich, 1970, p. 46). The fact
that Mineral Oil does not penetrate the skin well makes it inappropriate
for use in an absorption base in a skin cream of any kind. In fact, mineral
oil-containing cosmetics can produce symptoms similar to dry skin by inhibiting
the natural moisturizing factor of your skin. Petrolatum, Paraffin or Paraffin
oil and Propylene Glycol are other common cosmetic forms of Mineral Oil.
Toxic. Avoid them (Hampton). Has tendency to dissolve the skin's own natural
oil and thereby increase dehydration. Mineral oils have been found to be
probably the single greatest cause of breakouts in women who use a new
product (Chase). Serious carcinogens are commonly found in Mineral Oil.
MYTH #14: NATURAL COSMETICS
No artificial ingredients. Pure or from nature. There is no legal definition
for "natural" which is why you see it everywhere. A chemist's definition
of organic simply requires that the molecule contain carbon (Hampton).
In cosmetic terminology, the term "natural" usually means anything the
manufacturer wishes. There are no legal boundaries for the term. There
are no guidelines surrounding what can or cannot be inside a "natural"
product. Most cosmetics called "natural" still contain preservatives, coloring
agents, and all the other things you can think of that sound very unnatural
(Begoun).
MYTH #15: pH
The term pH stands for the power of the hydrogen atom. Skin and hair
do not have a pH. A scale from 0 to 14 is used to measure acidity and alkalinity
of solutions, and pH 7.0 is neutral. Acidity increases as the pH number
decreases, and alkalinity increases as the pH number increases. Usually
the pH of a cosmetic will not change the natural pH of the hair or skin
because the hair and skin contain keratin, fatty acids, and other substances
that adjust the pH levels with which they come into contact. As long as
a pH is not unusually high or low there is no problem - pH wise - with
a cosmetic.
Naturally the high pH of cold wave solutions and hair straighteners can
damage the hair and skin, but even this is rare providing a proper conditioner
or moisturizer is used after such pH alterations. There is no such thing
as a "pH balanced" product because a product's pH will drift during shelf
life and alter when applied to the hair and skin. A product's pH is not
a danger to the body, but the synthetic chemicals used in cosmetics often
to alter the pH to please the ones who fall for the "pH balanced" story
are (Hampton).
MYTH #16: PLACENTAL EXTRACT
Promoted for rejuvenating and nourishing aging skin. Placental Extracts
are another big hype. In moisturizers, these ingredients allegedly supplement
the vitamin and hormone content. The manufacturers of these products take
advantage of the belief that since the placenta nourishes the developing
embryo, an extract of it can nourish and rejuvenate aging skin. Placental
Extracts can do no such thing (Novick). The value of a cosmetic depends
on its active ingredients and with cosmetics containing "placental extract"
it is impossible to tell what you are getting (Chase). Temporary means
temporary, but it's still nice every now and then, to be able to get a
smoother look. Some ingredients include sodium silicate, bovine serum albumin,
and human placental protein (Bromberg). Worst yet many may come from aborted
fetuses or might not be properly sanitized.
MYTH #17: PROPYLENE GLYCOL
Being promoted as being a beneficial humectant. It is the most common
moisture-carrying vehicle, other than water, in cosmetics. It has better
permeation through the skin than Glycerin and is less expensive, although
it has been linked to more sensitivity reactions. Its use is being reduced
and it is being replaced by safer glycols (Winter). A moisturizer that
has been shown to provoke acne eruptions (Chase). See Humectants.
MYTH #18: ROYAL BEE JELLY
Promoted to nourish and moisturize the skin. This substance is found
in beehives. It is secreted from the digestive tubes of worker bees. The
male bees and the workers eat royal jelly for only a few days after they
are born, but the queen bee eats royal jelly all of her life. Because royal
jelly is associated with the health and long life of the queen bee, it
was believed that this substance could have some age-retarding properties.
It does not. There has been extensive research done on the value of royal
jelly, and the scientific consensus is that it is worthless for humans.
Anyone who claims that it has special powers is a fraud (Chase). Eggs,
milk, honey, and royal bee jelly are other favorites of some moisturizer
manufacturers. Without question, eggs are nourishing for the embryo, milk
nourishing and life-sustaining for infants, and honey and royal bee jelly
nectar for bees. When applied to the skin, however, they do little for
you, although they may give a moisturizer a smoother consistency or a lush
look (Novick). Royal bee jelly, highly touted as a magical ingredient in
cosmetics to restore one's skin to youthfulness. If stored for over 2 weeks,
royal jelly loses its capacity to develop queen bees. Even when fresh,
there is no proven value in a cosmetic preparation (Winter).
MYTH #19: SEAWEED
Promoted to nourish and moisturize the skin. This plant has gelatinous
properties. It is the major ingredient of the thin, clear masks that peel
off in one piece. These masks allow the skin to build up a supply of water.
Seaweed is also used in face creams and lotions where it gives body and
substance to the products, not to the skin (Chase).
MYTH #20: SODIUM CHLORIDE (Salt - NaCl)
Sodium cloride is used to increase the viscosity in some cosmetics.
It can cause eye and skin irritation if used in too high concentrations
(Hampton). Its usually used to make a cheap, watery consistency product
look thick and rich instead.
MYTH #21: SODIUM LAURETH SULFATE (SLES)
Chemical name: Sodium Lauryl "ether" Sulfate An ether chain is added
to SLS, and is called a premium agent in cleansers and shampoos. In reality
it is very inexpensive, but thickens when salt is added in the formula
and produces high levels of foam to give the concentrated illusion it is
thick, rich, and expensive. Used as a wetting agent in the textile industry,
SLES is irritating to scalp and may cause hair loss (Wright). SEE SODIUM
LAURYL SULFATE.
MYTH #22: SODIUM LAURYL SULFATE (SLS)
No one making any claims about this one - and for good reason. We examined
an anionic detergent, Sodium Lauryl Sulfate, which is commonly found in
soaps and shampoos, that showed penetration into the eyes, as well as systemic
tissues (brain, heart, liver, etc.). SLS also showed long-term retention
in tissues. Because SLS and related substances are widely used in many
populations on a daily basis in soaps and shampoos, there is an immediate
concern relating to the penetration of these chemicals into the eyes and
other tissues. This is especially important in infants, where considerable
growth is occurring, because a much greater uptake occurs by tissues of
younger eyes, and SLS changes the amounts of some proteins in cells from
eye tissues. Tissues of young eyes may be more susceptible to alternation
by SLS (Green). SLS forms nitrates, a possible carcinogen, when used in
shampoos and cleansers containing nitrogen-based ingredients. These nitrates
can enter the blood stream in large numbers from shampooing, bubble baths,
bath, and shower gels and facial cleansers. These synthetic substances
are used in shampoos for their detergent and foam-building abilities. They
can cause eye irritations, skin rashes, hair loss, scalp scurf similar
to dandruff, and allergic reactions. They are frequently disguised in pseudo-natural
cosmetics with the parenthetic explanation "comes from coconut." Let's
save the coconut from defamation of character and NOT use products with
sodium lauryl sulfate, etc.! (Hampton) Dr. David H. Fine, the chemist who
uncovered NDELA contamination in cosmetics, estimates that a person would
be applying 50 to 100 micrograms of nitrosamine to the skin each time he
or she used a nitrosamine-contaminated cosmetic. By comparison, a person
consuming sodium nitrite-preserved bacon is exposed to less than 1 microgram
of nitrosamine (Hampton).
MYTH #23: TYROSINE
An amino acid that can help you attain a deep, dark tan. Some tanning
accelerator lotions do contain Tyrosine. You can be sure they'll advertise
it if they do an amino acid that's essential to melanization (darkening)
of the skin. Melanization is an internal process and spreading lotion on
the skin's surface does nothing to fuel it. Similar logic would have us
trying to rub food through our pores to satisfy hunger (Matarasso). Manufacturers
claims for the efficacy of tan accelerators remain unproven; a recent,
independent study of these products failed to demonstrate any augmentation
of tanning. Indeed, it is doubtful that sufficient amounts of tyrosine
can penetrate to the level of the skin where it could enhance melanin production
(Novick).
MYTH #24: AHA's (Alpha Hydroxy Acids, i.e.: Glycolic, Lactic and
Others) Exfoliates the skin to remove wrinkles and expose young skin.
Removing the outer layer of the skin exposes the young skin to the harsh
aging and damaging environmental agents. Use of AHA's could make you age
much faster. You could look better today but may not be such a pretty sight
in 10 years. Your outer layer of skin is your first and most important
line of defense. Everything should be done to make it healthy and keep
it NOT LOSE IT. The FDA reported their deep concern about exfoliating the
stratum corneum, and the aging and health risks associated with this potentially
dangerous procedure. (May 1994)
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Begoin, Paula - Blue Eyeshadow Should Still Be Legal, Beginning Press,
1988 Brumberg, Elaine - Take Care of Your Skin, Harper & Row Publishers,
Inc.1989 Chase, Deborah - The New Medically-Based No-Nonsense Beauty Book,
Henry Holt and Co., 1989
Friend, Tim - "USA Today," 4-10-90
Green, Dr. Keith - Detergent Penetration Into Young and Adult Eyes
Department of Opthamology, Medical College of GA, Augusta, GA
Hampton, Aubrey - Dictionary of Cosmetic Ingredients Organica Press
Metarasso, Dr. Seth L. - "Faking It" - Muscle & Fitness, November,
1990
Novick, Dr. Nelson Lee - Super Skin, Clarkston, N. Potter, Inc., Publishers,
1988 Valmy, Christine & Vons Ulrich, Elise - "Mid-Air Skin Care" -
Entrepreneurial Woman, July/August 1990
Winter, Ruth - A Consumer's Dictionary of Cosmetic Ingredients, Crown
Publishers, Inc. 1989
Wright, Camille S. - Shampoo Report, Images International, Inc., 1989
Back To Toxic Home Articles
| Back to Articles and
Reference Guide | Back Home
|